Hello dear
Papa Joe's Italian Restaurant & Pizzeria, located at 814 Cape Coral Pkwy E, is a beloved local gem renowned for its authentic Italian cuisine. With a cozy atmosphere adorned with classic red tablecloths, the restaurant exudes warmth that feels like home. Customers rave about the homemade pasta, NY-style pizza, and vibrant dishes like the Papa Joe’s salad and Tortellini Alfredo. Consistent quality and flavorful meals shine through every customer review, emphasizing the restaurant's commitment to excellence. The attentive, friendly service ensures every visit feels special. Celebrating over 34 years, Papa Joe's is truly a Cape Coral treasure that keeps patrons returning for more.
About
Welcome to Papa Joe's Italian Restaurant & Pizzeria, a true gem nestled in the heart of Cape Coral, Florida. Located at 814 Cape Coral Pkwy E, this family-owned establishment has been delighting locals and visitors alike for over 34 years. If your taste buds crave authentic Italian cuisine, look no further—Papa Joe’s delivers a dining experience steeped in tradition and warmth.
As soon as you step through the doors, you're enveloped in a vibrant atmosphere that echoes the charm of Italy. With red-checkered tablecloths and an inviting ambiance, every meal feels like a family gathering. The restaurant prioritizes not only delectable food but also exceptional service, as evidenced by glowing reviews from patrons who have returned time and again. Customers rave about the fun and friendly servers, like Terry, who make dining at Papa Joe’s feel like home.
Now, let's talk about the food—oh, the food! From the very first bite, you'll understand why diners like Evelio Gonzalez describe it as "out of this world." The pizza, prepared in authentic New York style, boasts a perfectly crispy crust topped with rich, flavorful sauce and generous cheese. And if you're in the mood for pasta, you can't go wrong with their homemade creations like the Tortellini Alfredo or Chicken Maria—the flavors are a testament to the love and passion infused in each dish.
Many guests find themselves enchanted by the classic Papa Joe's Salad and the must-try Scratchatella Soup, while others sing praises for the delicious Eggplant Rolatini as a vegetarian delight. Each dish is crafted with care, using high-quality ingredients that ensure freshness and flavor in every bite. As customer Anais noted after two decades of dining at Papa Joe's, the food and service remain consistently amazing.
For a restaurant that manages to be both a lively pizzeria and a cozy family gathering spot, Papa Joe's offers a remarkable balance. The outdoor seating area provides a delightful option for those who wish to enjoy their meal al fresco, making it a perfect choice for sunny Florida days.
In summary, Papa Joe's Italian Restaurant & Pizzeria is not just a place to eat; it's a beloved culinary institution that has captured the hearts of many in Cape Coral. Whether you're a long-time patron or a newcomer, you’ll find that once you visit, you'll want to return again and again. So gather your family and friends, and let Papa Joe's whisk you away on a delicious Italian journey that you won't want to miss!
“ Terry is one of the best people I’ve ever had serve me. She is so so funny and so sweet. If you come here I highly recommend requesting her as your server. This is our second time here and the food is awesome. It still doesn’t disappoint and I would come here again and again. ”
“ If I could give 100 stars, I would! This is my second review, but easily the 1,000th time I’ve been here—and not once have I been disappointed. Papa Joe’s is more than just a restaurant, it’s a second home filled with warmth, flavor, and consistency that’s hard to find these days. The food? Out of this world. Every bite of pizza tastes like it was crafted by someone who genuinely loves what they do. The pasta? Homemade perfection. You can taste the passion in every dish. The service? Always welcoming, always friendly. They remember you, they care, and they treat you like family. This place is a Cape Coral treasure. If you haven’t been yet, you’re seriously missing out. And if you have—well, I’ll probably see you there again soon, because once you come, you always come back. Thank you Papa Joe’s for doing it right every single time. You guys are legends! ”
“ The best Italian food in Cape Coral. Been eating here for over 20 yrs and can say the food and service continues to be amazing. I always order the papa joes salad, scratchatella soup. My family enjoys the Tortellini Alfredo, Chicken Maria and eggplant rolatinni. The pizza is NY style and never fails to satisfy. I recommend this family owned restaurant 10/10. Outdoor seating is very nice too. ”
“ This is a classic Italian red table cloth amazing food n fun family restaurant. It was our 1st time eating here. Alfredo sauce is on point! A new regular on our list. Wine selection is limited but gets the job done. Very reasonable prices all around and generous portions. 34 years in business! ”
“ Never disappointed here. From pizza to any Italian style dish off the menu I’m always very happy after. Amazing concepts in food presentation. Dress the salads if asked, possibly the best antipasto I’ve ever had, soup is hot ( a real unicorn), and although I’m tired of hearing all the talk about gratuities out of control, here a large gratuity somehow doesn’t seem To be enough. Prices are in line with the average brain thinking. All area restaurants could learn something here. ”
“ We have finally gotten a table at Papa Joe's and it was worth the wait. Jackie was our waitress and she is the best. I told her it felt like we went to her house for dinner, she made us feel like family. We had the pizza and pastas, but the bread sticks alone were something to come back for. The place is small. The parking is limited. But if you haven't tried Joe's, it is a must eat for Cape Coral. ”
“ This locally owned gem is worth the wait! We visited on a Saturday night and it was packed, but we had a table in less than 30 minutes. The selections were varied and the food was delectable. It’s easy to see why they’ve earned all of the “Best of” awards hung on their walls. They offer all of the traditional Italian dishes, but the pasta with clams or mussels appeared to be a favorite with the other diners. The portions were large enough to need to go boxes. They offer vegetarian and gluten free options and were not put out at all when I inquired about these. Our waitress, Janice was wonderful! Give this memorable place a try! ”
“ Incredible staff... flavorful meal...fantastic bread on the table with our salads... house made sangria that I didn't try, but I saw many who did, so, next time!! (Side note, many SOLO diners, so my Mom felt she would be comfortable dining alone - that's a BIG DEAL!! - staff was gracious and just as energetic with a 1 top as they were with a 4 top)... ”